You know everything you do should be marked in red
Because it is just reencode of others releases

@ShareAnime let me remind you that I was releasing multi when you couldn’t, I rip the eps for DkB so stop whining, you should care more about your typsetting releases where the text goes off screen

@OASC-Rips

Red entries (remake) are torrents that match any of the following:

• Reencode of original release.
• Remux of another uploader’s original release for hardsubbing and/or fixing purposes.
• Reupload of original release using non-original file names.
• Reupload of original release with missing and/or unrelated additional files.

@ShareAnime https://nyaa.iss.one/rules only 1 line there mentions ‘remake’ and now I am part of DkB so I don’t see why it should be marked, but since mods let you be verified and miss days or weeks I guess we might have to, still we as a team rip

If you’re re-encoding existing rips that are uploaded on this site it should be marked red. If you’re doing your own rip and encoding from that it doesn’t need to be red.

@kokoro thank you for helping us, so we can keep uploading without red?. If we must use someone’s else original rip we will mark it red and state who’s original encode was

Yes you may upload normally without marking as remake if you’re just encoding your own ripped video currently.

@ShareAnime

They are riping their own Encode. i know them. So it Shouldn’t Be a Problem i think…

If you’re re-encoding existing rips that are uploaded on this site it should be marked red.

what is a rip?

If you’re doing your own rip and encoding from that it doesn’t need to be red.

okay so a WEBDL. but in that sense if one releases a disc rip, BDMV or DVDRemux, then all encodes made from such releases should be marked red.

would it be right to call encoding from a WEBDL a re-encode?

@kokoro Thanks for the info. We will keep this in mind from the next time.

I guess what Kokoro is trying to say is:
if you download something from nyaa and reencode it, it’s a remake and has to be marked red.
But if you download it from the streaming site (aka do a Web-DL) and then encode it, it’s not a remake since you didn’t take anything from nyaa, so you don’t need to mark it red.
Tbh I’d say that all web reencodes should be marked red, regardless of whether it’s an own rip or not. But as of now the rules don’t say that.

i think all streams acquired 1:1 from a streaming service or discs should be considered first rip. all encodes done from first rip shouldn’t be considered re-encodes, let’s call them first encodes. all encodes done from the first encodes should be considered re-encodes.

@sameer who tf encodes from those “first encodes” dude? I’ve never seen anyone re-encode a judas weekly release.

and Kokoro is absolutely right. If you encode from something taken from this website (obviously except bdmvs and all) then it should be marked as remake but if you do stuff on your own then you dont have to mark it anything.

you never saw them because they got nuked.

i think more clarity is needed with regards to what is / is not a re-encode, is having single eng dub/sub track in file enough for categorization under English-translated or do they have to be in a specific order, what is / is not an original release.